12.12 SrEyO hi gyAnam abhyAsAj

SrI:  SrImathE SatakOpAya nama:  SrImathE rAmAnujAya nama:  SrImath varavaramunayE nama:

Chapter 12

<< Chapter 12 verse 11

SlOkam – Original

SrEyO hi gyAnam abhyAsAj gyAnAdh dhyAnaṁ viSishyathE |
dhyAnAth karmapalathyAgas thyAgAch chAnthir anantharam ||

word-by-word meaning

abhyAsAth – better than devotion towards bhagavAn (without true love)
gyAnam – the knowledge which facilitates direct vision (which is the means for such devotional practice)
SrEya: hi – isn’t it better?
gyAnAth – better than the (incomplete) self-realisation
dhyAnam – meditation upon the self (which is means for self-realisation)
viSishyathE (hi) – isn’t it better?
dhyAnAth – better than (incomplete) meditation
karma pala thyAga: – karma (activities) performed giving up the fruit (which is the means for such meditation)
(viSishyathE (hi) – isn’t it better?)
thyAgAth – from engaging in karma yOga giving up the fruits
anantharam – subsequently
SAnthi: – peace of mind (occurs)

Simple Translation

Better than devotion towards bhagavAn (without true love) is the knowledge which facilitates direct vision (which is the means for such devotional practice); better than the (incomplete) self-realisation  is the meditation upon the self (which is means for self-realisation); better than the (incomplete) meditation is the karma (activities) performed giving up the fruit (which is the means for such meditation); engaging in karma yOga giving up the fruit leads to peace of mind.

Rendering based on ALkoNdavilli gOvindhAchArya swAmy’s English translation of gIthA bhAshyam

‘Next to (God-)devotion, (soul-)knowledge is preferable; next to (soul-)knowledge, (soul-)meditation is preferable; next to (soul-)meditation, surrender of work’s fruit; from surrender follows peace.’

If (God-)exercise or practising (God-)devotion constantly (=abhyāsa) (as a mere head-exercise) is hard, by reason of no response coming to it in the interests of the soul from the heart, then the next alternative is to attempt soul-exercise, or practise the akshara-path (Gi: XII-345) through which to attain to soul-vision (jñāna).

In the interests of the soul, next to the achievement of soul-vision (or soul-cognition), —not arising— the mere contemplation on soul-nature (dhyāna), (as Spiritual Books teach) is to be adopted as the next alternative.

If soul-contemplation be found hard to practise —then it is best to perform works, resigning fruits thereof. This would lead (gradually) to soul-contemplation.

Performing action this-wise; viz., —without interest in the reward,— results in the divorcement of sin; and thereafter comes peace of mind. (Thus):—

  1. From peace of mind comes soul-contemplation;
  2. From Soul-contemplation results soul-cognition.
  3. From soul-cognition arises Parā-bhakti (God-love)

 

Hence, to him who is inept for Bhakti-Yoga (=the Path of God-love), soul-devotion is recommended as (next) best; but to him who cannot bring a mind peaceful enough to try this, -let him devote himself to doing fruit-forsaken works, based on soul-faith. This would (gradually) lead to soul-contemplation and soul-vision (in order).

The qualifications required for such a disinterested worker are now enumerated:

>> Chapter 12 verse 13

archived in http://githa.koyil.org

pramEyam (goal) – http://koyil.org
pramANam (scriptures) – http://granthams.koyil.org
pramAthA (preceptors) – http://acharyas.koyil.org
SrIvaishNava education/kids portal – http://pillai.koyil.